The strong friendship of max and liesel in the book thief, a. What might hans be feeling when liesel says she is old enough to deal with her own nightmares. When she first comes to live with her foster family, the. Death says that liesel was a girl with a mountain to climb.
However, in the movie, liesel actually goes as far as to tell rudy about hiding max. Discussion points and guiding questions for the book thief. For liesel, the main character in the book thief by markus zusak, the answer to both of those questions is hans hubermann, her foster father. No matter the situations and surroundings, one can always find love and happiness. Compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max vandenberg. Both of the books titles are actually titles for liesel herself. Differences between the book thief book vs movie page 1. Oct 25, 2011 i read the book thief and am wondering what are some good compare and contrast points when looking at max and liesel. When max and liesel have a joyful reunion, its almost like the jewish fighter is punching hitler right in the face.
Compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max vandenburg. The mayors library becomes an even more important shelter now that liesels home life has become so suspenseful. It was a stuggle to max wondering when he was to be discovered and who would be the next person to walk through the door. Rosa, on the other hand, is usually very aggressive. Liesel usually finds hans, her foster father, to be quiet and uncomplicated.
In the movie, though, max is reading a newspaper and dismally says that germany is winning the war. Max gives liesel a story called, the standover man for her birthday. Liesel doesnt know about mein kampf or its significance she just wants to talk about books. Having lost her father because of his communist sympathies, and soon thereafter her brother and mother, she understands the pain of loss, and these experiences inform her actions and attitudes towards the other characters. Death tells us, though, that her soul was very much like her papas, how it rose up to meet him. Sure, she was a little girl, but little girls grow up, and liesel grew up into a woman who would be able to understand him better than most. The story dramatizes the way liesel has used words and books to create a refuge in the midst of nazi germany, and how shes invited max into that refuge. Another way they are similar is they are close to the same age, liesel being only 8 months younger than rudy. The book thief by markus zusak book club discussion.
How liesel s new ability to read helps her get smarter. Ilsa also encouraged a young liesel to start writing, even provided her with a blank book. The protagonist in this conflict is, liesel and the antagonist is liesel and stealing books. In the book of the book thief, liesel meminger learns through various ways that the nazi party is inimical. Compare the distractions liesel finds in rudys friendship with those in the whistler. However, max vandenburg and liesel meminger went against this abomination during this time and during their friendship max vandenburg gave many things to liesel. Ever since it was first published in 2005, the book became wildly popular and had won many awards. Jul 15, 20 liesel is traumatized by her brothers death, but hans proves to be a calming foster father. Rudy finds out about max after he has left the basement.
In the film, it was the blank book max had given liesel. What is the basis of the deep friendship that develops between max and liesel. If it had been the whistler, the hubermanns secret would have been kept long after max safely escaped the basement. Liesel has lost her mother and brother, and max doesnt even know the whereabouts of the family he left behind. The theme of the importance of words, speech and literature in the book thief novel table of contents. How the power of words differs in the everyday life and in the times of war. The novel is narrated by death, characterized not as the usual grim reaper, but a sympathetic guardian of the souls of the deceased.
Max apologizes that he doesnt have a present for her. Nobody can chop it down, but max is able to climb it and take shelter there with her. In addition, liesel begins using books to comfort the people in the shelter by reading to them. Maxs second serious illness, and liesels hysterical response when jewish prisoners are marched through town. Death visits himmel street, but he doesnt take max s struggling soul, and he doesnt see liesel. Max gives liesel a story called the standover man for her birthday. The book that was thrown into the river in the novel, was a book liesel had stolen to read to max. The book thief compare and contrast essay the book thief by markus zusak follows the struggles of a young girl in nazi germany during world war ii. The narrator refers to liesel as the book thief because she steals a. In the book thief compare and contrast the lives of liesel.
Liesel also brings max the newspaper so that he can do crossword puzzles. Feb 26, 2015 however, in the movie, liesel actually goes as far as to tell rudy about hiding max. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Liesel proves this to be true in the novel and the film the book thief. Mar 01, 2011 some of the differences about max and liesel are that liesel got away from being treated bad well somewhat. Both find refuge in the huberman home where they can articulate their fears and dreams to each other. The two adult children of hans and rosa hubermann geoffrey rush and emily watson, have been nixed from the story. What does death mean when he says, everything was good. The friendship between liesel and max in the last 100 pages that we have read, i must say that the friendship between max and liesel is one of the more important parts of the book. Both have left or been left by their families to live with the hubermanns. One of the most prominent of differences between the two characters is physical.
He discovers the secret of the books, and also the secret of max, whose. This is another indicator of how connected liesel and her papa were and continue to be even after his death. She uses words to develop relationships with her foster father, hans hubermann. Hamzeh karbais the last type of conflict that i am going to tell you is, liesel vs stealing books. When i read the book, i got the impression that max loved liesel because she was the only bright spot in a life filled with agony. In the book thief compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max. In the next couple slides we will answer the questions how does max s life give liesel purpose. After some initial resistance she manages to find love for her new family. Sep 23, 2010 write a 250word response based on our reading of the book thief pg. And while it may seem like i thought the movie was complete rubbish, that is really only in comparison to the original text. Liesel sits and talks to max, but he keeps sleeping for days. Without ilsas library liesel would not have been labeled the book thief. Aug 12, 2015 the book that was thrown into the river in the novel, was a book liesel had stolen to read to max.
Max wants to give her something, too, but he has nothing to give. Compare liesel and rudy in a venn diagram the book thief. These are just a few of the differences between the book and movie versions of the book thief. The book thief by markus zusak movie clip my preference the reasons for the movie change theme. Liesel and maxs relationship was defined by many things, books being one of them. The book gives liesel peace a respite from nightmares so is a comfort she was soon pleased she was awake, and able to read. In this section of the novel, max writes two books for liesel. The book thief is the story of liesel meminger, a girl living in nazi germany whose foster parents provide refuge for a young jew, max vandenberg, by hiding him in their basement. The book thief by markus zusak is set in nazi germany in world war ii. The power of words quotes in the book thief 2002 words. You must respond to this post as well as a fellow group members post. Liesel is marked out because her father was a communist and max is marked out because he is a jew. Study 35 terms book thief questions flashcards quizlet. Using death as the storys narrator, the book thief follows the life of liesel meminger, a young german girl who is sent to live with foster parents after her communist mother flees the country during hitlers rise to power.
Max needs liesel to brighten his life with stories from the outside world and to bring him the energy of youth. They both rely on each other for comfort, friendship, and trust as well. Jun 18, 2019 how does max vandenburgs life give liesel purpose in the book thief. For liesels 12th birthday, rosa and hans give her a book, the mud men. I also know from my background knowledge that max is a very nice guy, and he would do anything for his generous family since they havealready done enough. When we first meet max, he is in a train coming to molching, with a notecard with hans hermans information, who apparently knew max s father in the war. In february of 1941 liesel turns twelve, and the hubermanns give her a book called the mud men. For max, these times are loaded with conflicting emotions.
Rudy is motivated throughout the novel by his love for liesel. This scared german girl, liesel, fought and battled to survive in a wartorn society holding her tongue when there was injustice and learning the ro. Another book that defined theyre relationship was the standover man. Other than the nightmares, liesels connection to max stems from the fact that he has a book. For both characters, this loss haunts them like a plague. Max s illustrations provide a visual representation of how hitler and his nazis are controlling the minds of so many people, and how under nazi control, dead bodies pile up.
Write a 250word response based on our reading of the book thief pg. Some of the differences about max and liesel are that liesel got away from being treated bad well somewhat. Liesel benefits from max because she learns a lot about suffering and he is someone with whom she identifies. The protagonist of the book, liesel is also its moral center. The book max wrote liesel is extremely special, and symbolizes their tight bond and relationship.
Both max and liesel had family members taken away from them as a result of world war ii. Sep 28, 2010 comparecontrast liesel meminger and max vandenburg max vandenburg was a jew in hiding in the 1940s. Compare contrast liesel meminger and max vandenburg. He was staying place to place or more, storage unit to basements without a family, without any hope really. Which of the following school subjects does liesel practice regularly with max. The book thief, by mark zusak, is a novel that portrays the struggles of a young german girl living in nazi germany during the third reich. The last page is a picture of the basement, with the words painted on the wall next to a framed picture of max the bird embracing liesel. Death says that liesel is a girl with a mountain to climb. Max and liesel both have nightmares about their past and suffer from survivors guilt. Get an answer for in the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel and max.
Both liesel and max have lost or been separated from their families as a result of the war. Writing and reading was liesel s comfort and ilsa provided her with it in multiple ways. In his book ma x is a bird, the story is about all the people that have stood over him during his life, ending with liesel watching him sleep, and then the two trading dreams and becoming friends. Sketches cliffsnotes study guides book summaries, test. Which part of their relationship is a product of circumstance, and what do they have in common otherwise. He is the one who warms the readers heart in a novel. Without mien kemp, max would have never made it to molching alive, and leisel would have never had the courage to talk to him. Max is later moved to the basement so he can move around more, but it is colder in the basement and max becomes dangerously ill. The standover man, the word shaker maimstream englitch.
Zusak 161 max on the other hand had to go into hiding not seeing daylight in a long time always with a fear that someone would find him and take him away. In your response, compare and contrast the meaning behind both books and also mention why max only wanted liesel to read the word shaker when shes ready. She weaves her way toward him, and they fall into each others arms. The idea of a jewish male and a german girl becoming good acquaintances is an unimaginable, punishable thought in the time that the book thief is written. The strong friendship of max and liesel in the book thief. Once a reluctant soldier during world war i, he is a house painter and accordionist. In the book thief, liesel relates to max because they are in similar situations. Over the course of the novel, she befriends max, the jew who arrives to hide from the nazis in the hubermanns basement, and falls in love with rudy steiner, her best friend. Finally rosa makes liesel go out and play soccer to take a break. Liesels purpose contrast liesel s purpose max liesel comparison max is an inspiration max writes stories for liesel has a friend 247 learned from each other max gives liesel courage liesel relates to max both went through similar life look out for each other shows her the real. In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of.
Liesel helps max recover by reading to him every spare moment. Liesel is known to have complicated relationships with her foster parents. Liesel s words, you scared me, max, take on a double meaning in this chapter. The relationship of max and liesel by sharon lu on prezi. These periphery characters are not missed in the film, however. She calls out to max, reciting words to the book hed written for her. These are lines from, the standover man, max s loving gift to liesel on his birthday. Max and liesel have many similarities that help nurture their friendship. One way they are similar is because they both enjoy some of the same activities, like soccer and stealing.
What is the name of the book liesel writes after seeing max in the parade. He looks forward to their conversations in the basement. In the movie max dreams of becoming a boxer and fighting hitler. One day while borrowing a book from the mayors home, liesel is followed by rudy. In the book thief, compare and contrast the lives of liesel. The book thief is a 20 americangerman war drama film about a young girl living with her adoptive german family during the nazi era. Max opens his eyes twice but both times falls back into his coma. For max, simply surviving is an act of resistance against hitler. When death captures me, the boy vowed, he will feel my fist in his face. Here, death tells what has become of liesel so many years after the story of her life on himmel street and that she, too, is now dead. Another major difference between the two mediums is that, in the book, liesels best friend rudy learns that the hubermanns were hiding a jew only after max leaves the basement for reasons i will not tell you here.
But i believe that this is why they were able to develop such a special relationship. We will compare and contrast liesel and max, and we will explain the significence of the story the standover man you could argue. Mein kampf my struggle is an ironic reference when you compare liesel s and max s reallife struggles with the current powerful position of hitler. Start studying the book thief part 5 answers learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Max feels guilty for not preventing the ss from harming his family and liesel feels guilty that her brother died and she lived. I think that the reason that the directors and producers made changes to the novel is because first. From the book to the movie, there have been many changes in characters too. Max vandenburg and liesel meminger are characters in the book thief, a novel written by markus zusak. Narrated by death, the novel takes as its protagonist liesel meminger, a girl who grows up in a foster home where jews arent seen as evil, in a departure from attitudes in the rest of nazi germany. Ilsa knew that liesel was stealing her books, yet she never confronted or told on her.
As the book is set during the time period of world war ii in germany, the separation between the jews and the aryan race is an outstanding factor in peoples lives. A soldier tears her away, but liesel reenters the crowd. How is the relationship between hans and liesel and rosa. How does max vandenburgs life give liesel purpose in the. Rudy sees max s name written on one of liesel s books and discovers the secret of max while he is still in the basement. The characters liesel meminger and rudy stiener are very similar in many ways. How does max vandenburgs life give liesel purpose in the book thief. Comparative essay the book thief 1722 words bartleby. Bonding over nightmares, both the feeling of guilt, both found comfort in hans home etc. Its january 1939, and ten year old liesel is traveling by train with her mother and her little brother werner.
395 445 378 947 1502 1353 691 1211 34 1069 1449 985 573 204 1245 974 931 607 419 892 687 1443 70 16 780 1413 1318 905 555 52 684 1430 1280 372 81 847 800 186 111 784 868 113 1298